Teacher’s sheet
Racket Rocker Design Challenge
Each pair chooses one thing to improve on their finished Racket Rocker and takes it through a full design cycle: define the problem, generate and compare ideas, draw and make the new part, run a fair test, and evaluate the results.
- Length
- Follow-on lesson, about 45 minutes, after the build
- Grades
- 4 to 8, working in pairs
- Each pair needs
- Their finished Racket Rocker, carton board offcuts, glue, scissors, a ruler, a protractor, a pencil and the two-page student worksheet
The challenge for Racket Rocker
The suggested challenge is to make the drumstick lift higher before it strikes the drum. Pairs may change one part only: the drumstick, the connecting rod or the actuator. Everything else on the toy stays as it is.
How success is measured. Hold the ruler upright beside the drum. Work the actuator the same way each time and read, in millimetres, how high the tip of the drumstick rises above the drum.
Other challenges that work on this toy: make the drumstick strike nearer the centre of the drum (measure how far the strike lands from the centre), or make the handle stiffer (measure how far its end bends under one coin).
No engineering background is needed. The worksheet carries the method. The teacher’s part is to keep time, keep the tests fair, and keep asking “how do we know?”
Before the lesson
- Every pair has a finished toy that works.
- The class agrees one way of measuring, so that designs can be compared in step 5 and in Compare and Combine.
- Set the time limit for making the new part (12 minutes works well) and write it on the board.
- Scissors are in use again: the How-To, Safety & Pro Tips page has the safety points.
Running the lesson
| Step | Minutes | Students | Look for |
| 1. Define | 5 | Measure the toy as it is now, then define the problem in writing: what should change, the success test, and the limits. | A success test with a number and a unit. Limits written down, not just said. |
| 2. Generate and compare | 8 | Generate two or three ideas as sketches and compare them in the table against the success test and the limits. | Ideas that really differ. A choice that follows from the table. |
| 3. Draw and make | 12 | Draw the flat pattern for the new part at full size with ruler and protractor, then cut, fold and fit it. | A drawing with lengths and angles marked before any cutting. |
| 4. Fair test | 10 | Plan and carry out a fair test: three trials before the change (from step 1) and three after, measured the same way. | One change only. The same test every time. A note of where the mechanism sticks or fails. |
| 5. Evaluate | 10 | Swap with another pair and evaluate both designs in the rating table, then say which did best and why. | Reasons that point to the measurements. |
Grades 4 and 5, and Grades 6 to 8
- Grades 4 and 5: steps 1 to 5 as written. The success test can be simple: “higher than before, three times out of three.”
- Grades 6 to 8: the brief in step 1 also says who will use the toy and how re-used carton board limits or helps the design; the drawing in step 3 carries every length and angle; step 5 uses the full rating table.
- Optional write-up, Grades 6 to 8 (15 minutes or homework): each student writes the evaluation as an argument, with the measurements as evidence and an answer to the case for the other design.
Only twenty minutes? The Fair Test
The Fair Test sheet is step 4 on its own, done on the toy as built. Pairs pick one thing about how the toy is worked and test it both ways: how far the actuator is pushed, where the handle is held, or how tightly a fold is creased. They plan the test, carry it out three times each way, and identify where the mechanism sticks or fails and what could be improved.
Afterwards: Compare and Combine
A whole-class activity of 10 to 20 minutes, for a class in which several pairs took on the same challenge and measured it the same way. Each pair writes its result and one line about its changed part in a class table on the board. The class then analyzes the table: how are the designs that did best alike, and how do they differ from the ones that did least well? Each student names the best feature of two or three designs and sketches a new part that combines them. It is not for a student working alone.
Standards this lesson helps teachers address
| Part of the lesson | What the standard asks, in our words | NGSS or Common Core code |
| Step 1 | Define a design problem with its success tests and limits | 3-5-ETS1-1 (Grades 3 to 5); MS-ETS1-1 (Grades 6 to 8) |
| Step 2 | Generate several solutions and compare them | 3-5-ETS1-2 (Grades 3 to 5) |
| Step 4, and the Fair Test | Plan and carry out fair tests to find what can be improved | 3-5-ETS1-3 (Grades 3 to 5) |
| Step 5 | Evaluate competing designs by a systematic method | MS-ETS1-2 (Grades 6 to 8) |
| Optional write-up | Write an argument about the content of the subject | WHST.6-8.1 (Grades 6 to 8) |
| Compare and Combine | Analyze test data from several designs and combine their best features | MS-ETS1-3 (Grades 6 to 8) |
States and countries with their own documents use their own codes for these. The standards pages list them place by place.
Student worksheet · page 1 of 2
Racket Rocker Design Challenge
NamesDate
Engineers improve things one change at a time, and they prove the change worked. Our challenge: make our Racket Rocker better at one thing.
1. Define the problem
What do we want our Racket Rocker to do better? (Suggested: make the drumstick lift higher before it strikes the drum.)
How we will measure it. Hold the ruler upright beside the drum. Work the actuator the same way each time and read, in millimetres, how high the tip of the drumstick rises above the drum.
Right now it measures: mm mm mm (three trials)
We will call our design a success if:
Our limits. Material: carton board only. The one part we may change: Time to make it: minutes. The rest of the toy stays the same.
Grades 6 to 8: Who will use this toy, and what do they need from it? How does re-used carton board limit or help our design?
2. Generate ideas and compare them
Sketch two or three different ways to make the change.
| Idea | How well will it pass our success test? | Does it stay inside our limits? | What could go wrong? |
| A | | | |
| B | | | |
| C | | | |
We choose idea because:
Student worksheet · page 2 of 2
3. Draw the new part
Draw the flat pattern for the new part at full size, with ruler and protractor. Mark every length in millimetres and every angle in degrees. Solid lines are cut lines; dashed lines are fold lines. Then cut it, fold it and fit it.
4. Plan and carry out a fair test
The one thing we changed:
What we keep the same every time:
| Trial 1 | Trial 2 | Trial 3 |
| Before the change (mm) | | | |
| After the change (mm) | | | |
Where did the mechanism stick, bend or fail? What could still be improved?
5. Evaluate the designs
Swap toys with another pair. Rate both designs against the same four tests: 2 points if the design fully passes a test, 1 if it partly passes, 0 if it does not.
| Test | Our design | Their design |
| Passes the success test | | |
| Stays inside the limits | | |
| Works every time (three trials out of three) | | |
| Still does everything the toy did before | | |
| Total | | |
Which design did best, and why? Use the measurements.
Optional write-up, Grades 6 to 8: on a separate page, write an argument for the better design. State the claim, give the measurements as evidence, explain the reasons, and answer the best case for the other design.
Student worksheet · short activity, 10 to 20 minutes
Racket Rocker Fair Test
NamesDate
A fair test changes one thing and keeps everything else the same. Then we know what made the difference.
1. Plan the test
The one thing we will change (for example how far the actuator is pushed, where the handle is held, or how tightly a fold is creased):
What we will keep the same:
What we will measure: the height of the drumstick tip above the drum, in millimetres.
2. Carry out the test
| Trial 1 | Trial 2 | Trial 3 |
| First way (mm) | | | |
| Second way (mm) | | | |
3. Identify what can be improved
Where does the mechanism stick, bend or fail?
One thing about the toy that could be improved, and why:
Class sheet · short activity, 10 to 20 minutes, after the Design Challenge
Racket Rocker Compare and Combine
NameDate
1. Copy the class table
| Team | What they changed | Result (mm) |
| | |
| | |
| | |
| | |
| | |
| | |
2. Analyze the results
Two ways the designs that did best are alike:
Two ways they differ from the designs that did least well:
3. Combine the best features
The best feature of two or three designs:
Sketch a new part that combines them. Label each feature and the team it came from.
Answer key · for the teacher
Racket Rocker Design Challenge: what good answers look like
A design challenge has no single right answer. This key shows what a sound answer looks like at each step.
Starting measurement
Pairs measure their own toy first and set a target above it. No figure is given here: every toy is built a little differently, so starting measurements vary from pair to pair, and that is worth a sentence in class.
1. Define the problem
Sound: “We want to make the drumstick lift higher before it strikes the drum. Success: the height of the drumstick tip above the drum, in millimetres is greater than it is now in three trials out of three, and the toy still works as before. Limits: carton board only, one part changed, 12 minutes.” Not yet: “Make it better” (nothing to measure), or a brief with no limits.
Grades 6 to 8 add a user (a younger child needs a toy that survives rough handling; a performer needs one that works every time) and a point about the material (re-used carton board varies in thickness and bends more easily along its grain, so a part may need a second layer).
2. Generate ideas and compare them
Ideas that often come up on this toy: a longer drumstick, whose tip travels further for the same turn; moving the point where the connecting rod joins, since a join nearer the pivot gives more swing for the same push; and a longer or shorter connecting rod, which changes where the swing starts and ends.
The table matters more than the idea chosen. A sound table gives a reason in every box, and the choice follows from it.
3. Draw the new part
The drawing is at full size, with every length in millimetres and every angle in degrees, fold lines dashed, and a glue flap wherever the part must be joined.
4. Fair test
One thing changed. The ruler held in the same place and the toy worked the same way in all six trials. Results that vary a little from trial to trial are normal and worth a sentence. Common failure points: a part bends, a glue joint lifts, a part rubs on its neighbour, or the changed part no longer reaches where it should.
5. Evaluate
Totals follow the 2, 1, 0 rule, and both pairs use the same four tests. A sound conclusion names the better design and gives its measurements. A design can gain on the success test and still lose overall if the toy no longer does what it did before.
Fair Test
A sound plan names one change and at least two things kept the same. The conclusion says which way gave the larger measurement and points to a real weak spot on the toy.
Compare and Combine
Likenesses and differences point to the class table (“the three highest results all changed the same part”). The combined design takes named features from at least two teams.